Warning: This web at toLearn.net/marketing/ is two years old, it's unattended, and the links are rotting. However, in June 2000, the server recorded over 10,000 page requests during more than 3,000 visitor sessions from dozens of countries. Thus, I'm reluctant to take it down completely.

Get much of the info new and fresh:

Ricci Street | MBA 604 | marketing
computers | design | discussion forum


topbar.gif (10780 bytes)
assignmt.gif (3864 bytes)

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

oranlogo.gif (4389 bytes) Web Site Critique

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)
| Web Site Critique Form |
monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

While you're exploring and discovering, you also need to be training your eye. I'd like you to look at webs on two levels: content/marketing communication, and media. Take, for example, a site like our course web. Of course, you'll look at it as a student getting information from the instructors. I'd also like you to put on your new digital developer's hat and look at its shapes and colors and images.
  virtual mixed
provide
Information
news or entertainment
Nando Times
brochureware
Ethan Allen
perform
a function
Internet tasks
Liszt
direct sales
Cathay Pacific Airlines

For this assignment, I would like you to visit some sites (preferably related to your team project, but you may pick any site you wish), and take the class on a ten-minute tour of one of them. Your tour should elaborate and illustrate the short answers you will email to me when you submit the form below.

To get full credit, please respond to every one of these questions. Give short answers here and longer answers in the oral part of your presentation.

Tour Guide

Your Name

Title of Site

URL http://

Publisher:
(host, sponsor, copyright holder)

Last revision or copyright date:

Type of site (see table above):

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

Content

We'll pay special attention to content later. For the moment, choose only the site's primary purpose:

to inform
to educate
to entertain
to persuade (or sell)

Primary audience:

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

Structure

Navigation:

Does it make you wait or can you go anywhere anytime?
How long did it take you to learn to navigate comfortable?
Did a click ever take you somewhere you didn't expect to go? Yes    No
Are there enough links for both forward and backward movement? Yes    No

Organizing principle:

How is the site organized overall?
(examples: like a book; chronologically; product by product)

Could you draw a picture or diagram of that organization? To give you the maximum flexibility, use whatever medium you find    easiest -- from a paint program to a doodle on a dinner napkin -- and hand it in separately.

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

Language

First impression:

Can you can tell where you are immediately? Yes No
Do the opening screens have strong eye appeal?
(choose one from menu)
Do they make you want to continue exploring? Yes No

Graphics / sound / video:

decoration only
decoration and information
crucial to understanding

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

Mechanics

Frustration factor:

How fast did the page download? (choose one from menu)
If you had to wait, what seemed to slow it down?

one big graphic? Yes No
a large number of small graphics? Yes No
interactive or wizbang fancy stuff? Yes No

 

Was your computer able to handle all the fancy stuff?  Yes No

Did the wizbang stuff get in the way of the content?  Yes No

Vocabulary:

Did you see any objects you didn't know the name of? 
(examples: type of button; some geekspeak on an error message)
Please list them in the box below.

Further information:

Was a contact person or email address readily available? Yes No

monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

General

What did you like best?

What did you like least?

In print, how would it be done?

Person to person (no computers, no books, no pictures), how could it be done?

Overall rating

Comments about the site

Comments about this form




monobar.gif (1022 bytes)

Link to TALK (discussion forum)

These categories in the table at the top of the page need some thought. Donna L. Hoffman of Vanderbilt University uses different categories in "Commercial Scenarios for the Web".

As you were trying to fit sites into one of the four slots, did you think of criteria other than function and degree of virtuality that would be more useful for marketers?

duobar.gif (1186 bytes)

top.gif (255 bytes)

btmbar.gif (5494 bytes)
last update: November 15, 1998
http://toLearn.net/marketing/websitecrit.htm